When to Resurface vs. Replace Your Asphalt: A Homeowner's Guide
Your driveway is more than just a place to park—it's one of the first things visitors notice about your home. But when cracks start appearing or the surface begins to look worn, you're faced with an important question: should you resurface or completely replace your asphalt?
At J&J Asphalt, we've helped Middle Tennessee homeowners make this decision for over 30 years. The truth is, the answer isn't always straightforward, but understanding the key factors can save you thousands of dollars and years of hassle.
Understanding the Difference
Asphalt Resurfacing involves applying a fresh layer of asphalt over your existing driveway. Think of it like adding a new coat of paint to refresh a room—the foundation stays the same, but the surface gets renewed.
Complete Replacement means removing the old asphalt entirely and starting from scratch with a new base and surface. This is more like gutting a room down to the studs and rebuilding.
When Resurfacing Makes Sense
Resurfacing is typically the right choice when your driveway's foundation is still solid, but the surface has seen better days. Here's when we recommend it:
Surface-Level Issues Only
If your problems are mostly cosmetic—minor cracks, fading, or small areas of wear—resurfacing can restore your driveway's appearance and functionality at a fraction of replacement costs.
Age is on Your Side
For driveways that are 10-15 years old with proper maintenance history (regular sealcoating every 2-3 years), resurfacing can add another 10-15 years of life.
The Foundation is Intact
When the base layer underneath is still stable and properly draining water, you don't need to tear everything out. We'll check for signs that the foundation is sound, like minimal settling or shifting.
Budget Considerations
Resurfacing typically costs 40-60% less than full replacement, making it an excellent option when you want quality results without breaking the bank.
Minor Drainage Issues
Small drainage problems can often be corrected during the resurfacing process by adjusting the grade slightly with the new layer.
When Replacement is Necessary
Sometimes, resurfacing is just putting a bandage on a bigger problem. Here's when we'll recommend a complete replacement:
Structural Foundation Problems
If the base has failed, no amount of surface work will fix it. Signs include:
- Large areas of sinking or settling
- Significant potholes that go deep into the base
- Widespread alligator cracking (interconnected cracks that look like reptile skin)
- Major drainage issues causing standing water
Extensive Damage
When more than 30-40% of your driveway surface is damaged, replacement often becomes more cost-effective than extensive patching and resurfacing.
Age and Neglect
If your driveway is 20+ years old and hasn't been properly maintained, the damage has likely extended beyond the surface. At this point, starting fresh makes more financial sense.
Deep Cracks Throughout
Cracks wider than half an inch that run deep into the base indicate structural issues that resurfacing can't address.
Multiple Layers Already
If your driveway has been resurfaced multiple times before, adding another layer can create problems. Too many layers can lead to instability and accelerated deterioration.
Root Damage from Trees
Tree roots pushing up through your driveway indicate ongoing pressure from below. This requires removal, addressing the root issue (literally), and replacement.
The Honest Assessment
Here's what sets J&J Asphalt apart: we'll never recommend replacement when resurfacing will do the job. As a locally owned company that's been here for 30+ years—and plans to be here for 30 more—our reputation matters more than a single sale.
When you contact us for an evaluation, we'll:
- Inspect both the surface and foundation
- Test for drainage issues
- Assess the extent and depth of damage
- Review your driveway's history and age
- Provide honest recommendations with transparent pricing for both options
Making Your Decision: Key Questions to Ask
How old is your driveway?
- Under 15 years: Likely a candidate for resurfacing
- 15-20 years: Depends on maintenance and current condition
- Over 20 years: Often better to replace
What's your maintenance history?
- Regular sealcoating: Good candidate for resurfacing
- No maintenance: Likely needs replacement
What's your budget and timeline?
- Need to maximize budget now: Resurfacing might extend life 10-15 years
- Planning long-term investment: Replacement gives you 20-25+ years
How long do you plan to stay in your home?
- Selling soon: Resurfacing improves curb appeal cost-effectively
- Long-term home: Replacement might be the better investment
The Middle Tennessee Factor
Living in Middle Tennessee means your asphalt faces unique challenges: hot, humid summers that can soften asphalt, followed by freeze-thaw cycles in winter that exploit any existing cracks. This climate makes proper evaluation even more critical.
Regular maintenance is your best defense against needing premature replacement. That's why we recommend sealcoating every 2-3 years and addressing cracks promptly—it's the difference between needing to resurface at year 15 versus replacing at year 10.
Our Resurfacing Process
When resurfacing is the right choice, here's what you can expect from J&J Asphalt:
- Thorough Cleaning - We remove all debris, vegetation, and loose material
- Crack Repair - All cracks are properly filled and sealed
- Edge Preparation - Edges are cut cleanly for proper bonding
- Tack Coat Application - A bonding agent ensures the new layer adheres perfectly
- New Asphalt Layer - Typically 1.5-2 inches of fresh, hot-mix asphalt
- Proper Compaction - Professional equipment ensures a smooth, durable finish
- Edge Work - Clean, professional edges that look great
The Bottom Line
The decision between resurfacing and replacement isn't just about current cost—it's about long-term value. Here's our simple rule of thumb:
Choose Resurfacing If:
- Your driveway is under 15 years old
- Damage is primarily surface-level
- The foundation is solid
- You've maintained it reasonably well
- Budget is a primary concern
Choose Replacement If:
- Structural or foundation issues exist
- The driveway is 20+ years old
- Damage is extensive (over 30-40% of surface)
- Major drainage problems persist
- You want a 20+ year solution
Ready to Make the Right Decision?
Don't guess about something this important. J&J Asphalt offers free, no-pressure evaluations throughout Middle Tennessee—from Nashville to Columbia, Murfreesboro to Clarksville, and everywhere in between.
We'll give you the honest assessment you deserve, explain your options clearly, and provide fair pricing for quality work that lasts. Unlike out-of-town contractors who are "here today, gone tomorrow," we're your local partner for the long haul.
Contact J&J Asphalt today for your free evaluation. With over 30 years of experience and a commitment to customer satisfaction, we'll help you make the decision that's right for your home and budget.

